In the neighborhoods of Philadelphia, where stray cats roam the streets in abundance, Emily has made it her mission to help control the population through TNR—trap, neuter, and release.
Living in an area where “stray cats are the norm” and people regularly abandon their pets, she’s become accustomed to the constant cycle of new cats appearing on her block every few weeks.
It was the fall of 2023 when Emily first noticed a medium-haired tabby cat lurking around her neighborhood. The cat showed no interest in human interaction, appearing only occasionally before disappearing again.
Determined to add this newcomer to her TNR efforts, Emily set her trap multiple times, but the wary tabby refused to take the bait.
On one particular day, Emily positioned her trap on the porch and waited inside, listening for the telltale sound of success.
When she heard the trap spring and the subsequent “lots of rattling,” she rushed outside expecting to find the elusive tabby. Instead, she discovered something entirely unexpected.
“I did not get the tabby cat. Instead I got what I called monster,” Emily recalls. “Monster was the biggest cat I had ever seen.”
The massive cat was clearly distressed, hissing and rocking the trap with such force that Emily worried he might escape.
His size was impressive, but what caught her attention immediately were the obvious signs that he hadn’t been neutered—no ear tip indicating previous TNR work, giant cheeks, and the unmistakable build of an intact male cat.
“The whole time I remember thinking to myself, I’m scared this cat is going to get out, it’s going to attack me,” Emily says. “He was really making his displeasure known.”
Despite her apprehension, Emily covered the trap and transported the angry feline to the clinic.
His behavior continued to align with that of a completely feral cat—so much so that clinic staff placed a warning sign on his trap reading “feral, use divider” to prevent anyone from accidentally getting too close.
The timing seemed fitting. With Halloween approaching and the cat’s intimidating presence, Emily’s friend jokingly suggested calling him “Monster Mash.” The name stuck immediately.
After his neuter surgery and vaccinations, Monster Mash was released back to Emily’s block, where he essentially vanished from sight.
For nearly a year, Emily rarely saw him in person, catching only glimpses through her feeding station camera as he squeezed his large frame through porch bars to eat in the early morning hours.
“I remember giggling because he was so large, we were like what is he eating out there?” Emily laughs, recalling how he had to contort himself to reach the food.
Neighbors occasionally spotted the mysterious large cat with the telltale ear tip, always asking Emily about the unfriendly giant who showed no interest in human contact.
Unlike other cats in the area who gradually warmed up to people, Monster Mash remained completely aloof.
Everything changed about ten months after his TNR procedure. Emily was working with several other cats who were becoming friendlier, spending time outside socializing them with treats and attention.
These cats eventually found loving homes, but during this process, Monster Mash began lingering closer to the action.
“He was like, oh, food, I’m interested,” Emily explains. “He still wasn’t coming up to me, but he would kind of get within the vicinity of the other cats.”
During this period, Monster Mash’s personality as the neighborhood bully became apparent. While Emily never witnessed actual fights, she frequently heard him “screaming” at other cats and intimidating them from the shadows.
His presence was felt, if not always seen.
Then came the breakthrough moment. Emily was sitting on her porch with a neighbor, offering treats to one of the friendlier cats, when something extraordinary happened.
“Monster Mash just started coming closer and closer and started taking my churu,” Emily remembers. “And I was like, what is going on? We had a whole like something in the universe is aligning.”
Her neighbor, aware of Emily’s recent experience being bitten by another cat, jokingly warned, “Are you sure you want to get bitten again?” But Emily decided to test the waters, moving closer and offering Monster Mash treats directly.
What happened next surprised everyone: “The magical moment happened where he was like, he bumped his head into my hand and started like bumping me, asking for pets.”
“And I was giving him pets and he was purring and rubbing up against the porch and rubbing up against me.”
The transformation was complete and immediate. Monster Mash became what Emily describes as “such a purr machine,” greeting her enthusiastically whenever she appeared on the block and even allowing other neighbors to pet him.
The switch from feral to friendly had flipped entirely. “We were like, is this the same cat? Definitely was the same cat. We had pictures of him. We were certain it was the same cat.”
With Monster Mash now friendly, Emily knew she needed to find him a permanent home. However, his history as a bully around other cats made her hesitant to bring him into her own multi-pet household.
She began exploring foster options, but fate had other plans.
One morning, Monster Mash appeared with “pus running out of his mouth and a giant swollen cheek.” The medical emergency accelerated Emily’s timeline. She scooped up the 16-pound cat and placed him in her bathroom while reaching out for help through her rescue network.
The House of the Cat Rescue, led by Nicole, stepped in to provide medical care. A veterinary examination revealed an abscess that had ruptured, requiring antibiotics but fortunately nothing more serious than initially feared.
During his recovery in Emily’s bathroom, Monster Mash’s gentle nature became even more apparent. “He was like, okay, cool. We’re here now,” Emily says.
“Every time I walked in, he would greet me with purrs and he’s a biscuit making machine.”
After his abscess healed, Emily decided to attempt integrating Monster Mash into her household. Ironically, the cat she’d worried would bully her pets turned out to be the one who needed protection.
Her existing cat became the dominant one, though the two quickly became inseparable friends.
“Him and my cat are now the best of friends. My cat loves to groom Monster Mash. They roll around together, they wrestle, they look out the window together, they play together, they are just the best of friends.”
The integration with Emily’s 60-pound pit bull took more time, with both animals initially intimidated by each other. Eventually, they learned to coexist peacefully, united by their shared love of snuggling.
Today, Monster Mash is a completely different cat from the angry, hissing feral Emily first trapped.
“He loves to sit in my lap. He loves attention. Anytime anybody walks into the house, he screams for attention,” she says.
Emily ultimately decided to adopt Monster Mash permanently, unable to part with the formerly feral giant who had become such a gentle companion.
His story has become legendary in her neighborhood and among her rescue community.
“I love sharing his story to show that it just takes time sometimes to build the trust,” Emily reflects, “but ultimately, even the 16-pound bully of a cat can be a mushy baby who makes you biscuits every morning.”
Monster Mash’s journey from feral street cat to beloved family member serves as a powerful reminder that with patience, compassion, and sometimes a little luck, even the most unlikely animals can find their way home.
Take a look at the video below:
If you liked this, then please share our story:
And while you’re at it, leave a comment and tell us what you thought!
Read More https://welovecatsandkittens.com/cat-stories/monster-mash/